Projects

Two men on IMTA platform in water.

 

From aquaculture to sustainable fisheries, UNH researchers are involved in various multidisciplanary projects, including:

Current CSSS Projects

With aquaculture as a rapidly growing source of food across the globe, UNH seeks to explore the cutting edge of aquaculture technology to ensure a responsible and sustainable future for the industry. Much like land-based agriculture, aquaculture can be done in ways that maximize the economic and health benefits to the community, while potentially benefiting the environment. One such technology is Integrated multi-trophic aquaculture, or IMTA. This method addresses concerns about nutrient loading in aquaculture by utilizing additional farmed products to remove excess nutrients, which typically enter the environment in the form of fish waste. In large fish farms, the waste from the fish add nutrients to the water, and in areas without much water flow, or areas that already have a high nutrient load, this could degrade water quality. With IMTA, additional products are grown with the fish, such as algae and shellfish, which will grow by removing and absorbing the excess nutrients. In NH, Dr. Michael Chambers with NH Sea Grant and the UNH School of Marine Science and Ocean Engineering have explored this practice in a model named AquaFort, which raises steelhead trout in net pens with sugar kelp and blue mussels on lines outside of the nets.

Three photos showing the IMTA system on water.

The IMTA system is sized so that the extractive species, such as mussels and kelp, absorb an equal amount (or more!) of the solid and dissolved nutrients as produced by the high valued fed species like steelhead trout. This effectively produces a system that could enhance the environment.

Species profiles

Steelhead trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

This salmonid species is native to the North American West Coast but has been stocked by state and federal hatcheries in rivers and streams for decades in the East for recreational anglers. Steelhead trout are diadromous fish, meaning they use both freshwater and saltwater habitats to complete their lifecycle. In freshwater, they are referred to as “rainbow” trout. When they get to salt water, they are then referred to as “steelhead”. The steelhead raised in AquaFort are hatched locally at the Sumner Summer Brook Trout Farm in Ossipee, NH, and transferred to a saltwater pen when they are close to 200 g. They can grow from 200 g to 4 kg in less than a year. These fish have a high market value, and show great potential to be an economically important fish in U.S aquaculture. These fish are sold to local seafood markets in Portsmouth such as Seaport Fish, Row 34 in Portsmouth and Sanders Fish Market.

Underwater photo of school of fish.
 

Blue mussels (Mytilus edulis)

Blue mussels are a common bivalve species in North America. These shellfish can be farmed on various submerge or vertical ocean deployed systems. Since mussels are filter feeders, they take water in through their siphon, consume the organic material in the water, and pump out the clean water. This makes them a great co-species to raise with steelhead trout, as the mussels are able to consistently filter water through most conditions. When raising mussels in the North Atlantic, farmers must be aware of shellfish closures and restrictions, and be prepared for predation by birds, especially eider ducks. The mussels raised in AquaFort are wild mussels, meaning they are collected as wild larvae. This is done simply by deploying “fuzzy” rope, which provides extra surface area for larval mussels to easily settle on. After some time they grow on the line and begin filtering nutrients from the water.

Color photo of pile of mussels.
 

Sugar kelp (Saccharina latissima)

Sugar kelp is a macroalgae species that is also common throughout the North Atlantic. This species is ecologically important because it provides habitat and nutrients for countless marine organisms. Farming of kelp has grown tremendously due to its nutritional benefits for people, has potential as feed for livestock and perhaps as a basis for producing biofuel.  In AquaFort, this crop absorbs dissolved nutrients from steelhead trout.  It also grows best throughout the Winter and Spring and therefore complements many fishing industries. Sugar kelp can come from recently selected strains, or wild strains that are grown on a seed line in a closed system. After it sets on the twine, it can be deployed in the farm. The sugar kelp found on AquaFort comes from Atlantic Sea Farms in Biddeford ME. When it’s ready to harvest, look for it at the Portsmouth Brewery, where it becomes an ingredient in their “Selkie” ale. 

Color photo of kelp.

 

The AquaFort Structure

With the UNH AquaFort, all three species are raised on a single platform system. The platform has two separate bays, which each hold a net. The fish school inside the net, and mussel lines and kelp lines hang around the outside, creating a biological “curtain” to ensure they maximize their impact on the fish waste. The platform itself is a floating frame made with HDPE, and it is anchored on two sides to prevent it from moving in the changing tides and current. The fish need to be fed and monitored daily, with their welfare and growth being priorities. The mussels and kelp thrive without much interference, and offer habitat for wild species like lumpfish and gunnel fish.

Color illustration of AquaFort.

The AquaFort system concept: One structure for three seafood products.

 

Overhead view of the IMTA model.

Overhead view of the IMTA model.

 

Where IMTA stands now

Trialing multiple seasons of IMTA with steelhead trout, kelp, and mussels has yielded exciting results. Not only does this strategy remove excess nutrients from the fish, but the kelp and mussels have sequestered additional nitrogen from the environment. This indicates that utilizing IMTA in regions that nitrogen and other nutrients are a concern might benefit the quality of the water, and ultimately help the environment.

Four color photos of aquaculture.
Another important consideration is climate change and warming in the Gulf of Maine, and how it effects seafood. Steelhead trout are a cold-water fish, and require cool, highly oxygenated water to thrive. As coastal waters in NH continue to warm, summer temperatures are often too hot for steelhead. To maintain the health and wellbeing of the fish, the grow out season was changed from summer/autumn to winter/spring. This keeps the fish cool and reduces the chances for temperature related health issues. Additionally, a cold weather season reduces the presence of parasitic sea lice, which are a problematic pest in salmonid aquaculture (See the Fairchild lab for more). Another benefit of a cold weather grow out is a reduction of biofouling, or unwanted growth on the nets.

The research on integrated multi-trophic aquaculture continues. Future aspects will look at land based IMTA, varying the species grown in AquaFort, and looking at expanding the AquaFort model to other parts of the United States, and beyond. Please check back to see additional publications and updates on the future of IMTA.

IMTA Outreach & Events

Illustration of ropeless aquaculture.

A general schematic of the ropeless aquaculture system deployed including a release mechanism, shellfish “condos” and pyramid anchor.


​​A pilot project to develop a bottom cage blue mussel aquaculture industry with offshore implantations. 

Center leadership including David Fredriksson, Michael Chambers and researchers are working with NOAA partners Matthew Bowden, Richards Sunny and Lisa Milke to expand aquaculture opportunities in the Northeast by exploring bottom culture of shellfish using methods that do not require vertical lines, which reduces risk of entanglement by marine mammals, especially the critically endangered North Atlantic Right Whale.

This project, funded by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission, is exploring gear that can grow shellfish on the ocean bottom, but do not have rope going to the surface. Instead, retrieval rope is kept coiled on the bottom with a secured, small float. To monitor or harvest the shellfish, a device is activated to release a small float, uncoiling the rope to the surface so that the farmer can recover the gear. Three systems are being tested in NH waters. Two of which are remotely activated acoustic releases and the third a time released trigger.

Photo of two men on boat with aquaculture cages.

The Aquaculture team preparing to deploy one of the ropeless gear configurations at the Isles of Shoals Mariculture site. The ropeless gear includes shellfish “condos” with mussels, oysters, and scallops. The release mechanism pictured fills a lift bag from compressed air once activated by an acoustic system sent from the surface.

The systems that utilize the acoustic releases are incorporated into wire mesh cages, like a lobster trap, so they can be deployed using fishing boat gear. To recover the bottom-mounted gear, a specific code is entered into a deck box unit that sends a unique signal to the release mechanism on the bottom. For one of the systems, the signal activates a mechanism unscrewing a component to release the rope and buoy to the surface. For the other system, the acoustic signal activates the release of compressed air from a tank filling a lift bag that brings the entire wire mesh pot to the surface, while still connected to the bottom shellfish gear with a rope. Once on the surface the rope is used to haul the shellfish cages.

The third system being investigated consists of a simple timed-released mechanism. The mechanism is set prior to deployment to releases a rope and buoy after a set amount of time. In this case the farmer can easily schedule a time to pick up the gear, while maintaining a farm without vertical lines.

Each of these methods is being tested at three sites off the coast of NH with the help of local shellfish farmers: Isles of Shoals Mariculture and Swell Oyster Company. We will also be collecting data on shellfish growth at each site. A bottom-mounted instrument package was also deployed at one of the sites to measure velocity profile (including at the level of the cages) along with temperature, dissolved oxygen, turbidity and chlorophyll-a. At the end of this study we will have a better understanding of some of the best methods shellfish farmers can use to raise blue mussels, scallops, and oysters while eliminating the need to keep vertical ropes in the water. This will ultimately contribute to a healthy and sustainable seafood community.

Video: A 30-second embedded video of Erich launching some gear off of Pete’s boat.

Rendering showing the components of an open ocean macroalgae farm.

Figure 1: Rendering showing the components of an open ocean macroalgae farm using a novel mooring system and wave powered upwellers developed through this ARPA-e funded project.


In a project led by Beth Zotter at Umaro Foods, members of the Center for Sustainable Seafood Systems, Michael Chambers, Zach Moscicki, Rob Swift and Igor Tsukrov are working in collaboration with Otherlab, Kelson Marine and Stationkeep LLC to develop an entanglement resistant, low-cost system for cultivating macroalgae, such as Saccharina latissima (sugar kelp) in the open ocean. The project is part of a larger national effort funded by the US Department of Energy ARPA-E’s MARINER program to develop technologies that can enable large-scale macroalgae cultivation for the purpose of generating material for sustainable food, feed and biofuel.

The novel farming system, as shown in Figure 1, is designed with limited use of rope that can pose an entanglement risk to marine animals, particularly when slack. Instead, the mooring and kelp substrate components are comprised of tensioned semi-rigid fiberglass rods that resist bending. We hypothesize that this would allow better shedding of the gear during a potential interaction event with marine mammals, however quantifying what would occur in such an event requires further study. The fiberglass rods used also break at a specific bending radius, so wrapping or knotting around flukes, flippers, jaws, etc. would be greatly minimized. The system is also feature minimal anchor scope (ratio of line length to depth) and helical embedment anchors; helping to minimize scenarios of reduced system tension.

A composite image: with a 3D rendering of the mooring and cultivation pilot scale system deployed in Saco Bay, ME with an overlaid photo of the actual surface components at the site.

A composite image: with a 3D rendering of the mooring and cultivation pilot scale system deployed in Saco Bay, ME with an overlaid photo of the actual surface components at the site.


In addition to addressing entanglement risks, the design must also be cost-effective. Therefore, to approach economic feasibility our system integrates: (1) minimized scope to reduce required seabed footprint, (2) using single novel multi-shaft helical anchors to support multiple mooring attachments, (3) an overlapping modular design to maximize horizontal growing area per farm area and provide flexibility for piecemeal farm expansion, (4) minimized mooring equipment scales and infrastructure through distribution of hydrodynamic loads to localized mooring points and (5) 0ptional wave-powered upwellers can be included to enhance nutrient availability to maximize growth rates.

The kelp farm was field tested at an Experimental Lease, granted to the University of New England by the State of Maine in Saco Bay. The system is shown in Figure 1 that combines an actual surface picture with a rendering of the submerged gear. It was deployed, seeded, and monitored at the site from November 2021 – May 2022. Though nearshore, the site is exposed to the open ocean and sees annual maximum wave heights on the order of 6.1 m (20 ft). Over 1800ft of kelp cultivation rod were planted over 4 farm modules.

Low cost and readily available, fiberglass rebar was tested as anchor and kelp cultivation components. A novel multi-shaft anchor was deployed using a robotic anchoring tool and tested as part of the farm mooring system. Helical anchors moored the low scope anchor lines and were tested for pull out strength at the end of the season. Tension loads on six anchor lines, waves and currents were also measured throughout the season. A prototype wave-powered upweller device was tested at a separate site. Together, the observations and data collected through this field season are helping to establish and test farm operations, validate our numerical modelling tools, inform our economic analysis, and evaluate the cultivation structure and component technology performance. Equipped with this data and tools we intend to iteratively improve our designs towards economic feasibility.

Color photo of man deploying instrument from boat.

Deployment of a current and wave measuring ADCP near the Saco Bay pilot farm from the Gulf Challenger to quantify forcing on the kelp farm system.

 

Load cells were deployed in-line with the mooring components.

Load cells were deployed in-line with the mooring components (left) beneath the tensioning buoys to measure tension response to waves and currents. The datasets were transmitted through a telemetry system incorporated with the surface buoy.

 

Blue and white graph depicting the hydrodynamic loads and distribution to the anchor points.

Numerical models are being developed to analyze the hydrodynamic loads and distribution to the anchor points.  (image from Maine Marine Composites).

Color photo of chain fall system.

Figure 1: A chain fall system was used in the testing apparatus to pull on the fiberglass rebar in bending. This setup was conducted in an effort to represent how a whale may break the rebar during an interaction event.  

One area of focus for the Center is to conduct research to develop marine mammal-safe mooring Systems. In a project funded by the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) called “Advancement of Composite Kelp Cultivation Lines to Mitigate the Risk of Marine Mammal Entanglement” we are assessing the engineering properties of the fiberglass rebar that was deployed as a part of the project “Development and Testing of a Novel Macroalgae Cultivation System for Exposed and Offshore Environments.” This effort includes Graduate Students Louis Gitelman and Zachary Moscicki, UNH professors and research personnel Igor Tsukrov, Michael Chambers, Rob Swift, Noah MacAdam, and Sustainable Seafood Systems Director David Fredriksson. We are also working with industry partners Pete Lynn and Beth Zotter. 

The significance of this research is immense. Entanglement in rope-based fishing gear has led to 27 of the 54 known deaths and serious injury events in the critically endangered North Atlantic Right Whale (NARW) from 2017 to 2022. While the fiberglass rebar shows great potential as an alternative to rope, engineering properties of the material used in this application are being investigated with the WWF funding. Laboratory tests are being conducted to examine tensile load capacities with terminations and breaking characteristics at specific forcing configurations related to NARW morphology.  

As part of the project, a novel testing rig was developed as shown in the photo above right. Tests were conducted pulling on a sample of the fiberglass rebar at specific bending radius values. An inline load cell was used to measure force time series during the breaking process. This information is being used to assess potential whale loading configurations and how the fiberglass rebar responds.

Video: An example of a pull test using the rig to the point of breakage in bending.
 

Color photo of rods with seaweed on dock.

Figure 2: Ocean water exposure test.

Composite rod samples are also undergoing exposure experiments to determine their susceptibility to ocean water-induced degradation. The figure to the right shows biofouling growth that could affect material properties.

Figure 2 (left): Various varieties of composite rods undergoing long-term ocean water exposure testing.

Mike Doherty and Michael Chambers prepare the non-rope samples to be painted on the IMTA platform in Portsmouth, NH.

Michael Chambers and Mike Doherty prepare the non-rope samples to be painted with kelp sporophytes on the IMTA platform in Portsmouth, NH. Samples were tested will different drying time periods (0-10 min, 30 min, 60 min, 24 hour).

Traditional kelp farming requires hatcheries, which are time and labor intensive (Coleman et al., 2022a), and ropes for kelp substrate, which can be a potential hazard to whales and other marine life. At UNH, Mike Coogan and the Center for Sustainable Seafood Systems have partnered with Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution researchers Scott Lindell and Dave Bailey to optimize kelp seeding methodology and in an effort to address these two issues.

A pilot project is currently being conducted off the Integrated Multi-Trophic Aquaculture (IMTA) platform “Aquafort” in Portsmouth Harbor, NH. As part of the project, sugar kelp sporophytes were painted onto foot long pieces of fiberglass rebar using four different adhesion techniques each tested at four different drying times. Fiberglass rebar is a material being tested at UNH researchers as a whale safe alternative to the rope traditionally used in aquaculture and fishing.

The first adhesion technique involves simply painting the kelp sporophytes directly on the fiberglass rebar. The second treatment adds a binder to the fiberglass rebar after painting the sporophytes to potentially increase settlement. With the third technique the fiberglass rebar was wrapped with cotton gauze and the sporophytes were painted directly on the gauze without a binder. The last technique involves wrapping the fiberglass rebar with polyester braided rope and painting the sporophytes directly on the wrapping without a binder to better simulate traditional growing substrate.

After painting on the sporophytes using each technique, the footlong rods were allowed to dry for four different time intervals (0-10 min, 30 min, 60 min, 24 hours) before being suspended off the AquaFort for growout. The kelp will be left in the water for 2 months and growth and settlement will be monitored. By determining optimal drying times, we can potentially reduce the amount of time and resources the kelp uses on land and convert that into growth and environmental benefits in the water.

Four types of rebar laid out.

The kelp sporophyte adhesion techniques are being tested on different substrates that include (from left to right), fiberglass rebar without binder, fiberglass rebar with binder, fiberglass rebar wrapped in cotton gauze without binder, fiberglass rebar wrapped in polyester braided rope without binder.

 

A hand holding a test tube water sample on the platform.

Kelp sporophytes produced by researchers Scott Lindell and Dave Bailey at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute.

 

A hand shown painting the rebar with a brush.

Kelp sporophytes being painted onto fiberglass rebar.

 

Center Director Dave Fredriksson is working with an interdisciplinary team from the University of Maine (Damian Brady, Struan Coleman, Adam St. Gelais, Kelly Cole), Kelson Marine (Toby Dewhurst, Michael MacNicoll) and Conscience Bay Research (Eric Laufer) in an effort to quantify the feasibility of using kelp as a method for Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR).

While much more work is needed, especially to understand the ecological impact of this technique, the work has been published in Coleman et al., (2022a) and Coleman et al., (2022b).

Color illustration of the continental shelf and processes.

Conceptual diagram of offshore macroalgae cultivation in the Gulf of Maine and intentional deep-ocean sinking as a method of carbon dioxide removal (CDR). Juvenile sporophytes are grown within a land based nursery during the summer and then outplanted on twine-wrapped PVC “spools” in the fall. The cultivation site is located ~20km from the Maine coastline. As kelp uptake dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) to build tissue, the DIC deficient seawater equilibrates with the atmosphere and draws down atmospheric CO2 into the oceanic C pool.

In the spring, kelp biomass is harvested and then transported ~350 km using ocean-going barges to the deep-ocean “sink site” located at the edge of the continental shelf. Biomass is ballasted using reclaimed concrete and deposited below the Carbon Sequestration Horizon (1,000 m). Lastly, a combination of in situ measurements and modeling is used to verify the quantity of CO2eq sequestered.


Learn about how our Aquaculture researcher colleagues at the UNH College of Life Sciences & Agriculture (COLSA) are investigating new and innovative methods of sustainable fishing, reducing prevalence of aquatic animal disease, and leveraging the many ecosystem services that marine life can provide:

COLSA Aquaculture Research